|
A Mission in Magnets
by Frank Stephenson
Seems as though you could've blinked and missed it. This fall,
Florida State University is winding down what surely has
to be the fastest four-year period in its 47-year history.
Only four summers ago, the world's scientific community got
the sobering news that the federal government had
decided to put the seat of its newest national laboratory--a
multimillion-dollar research enterprise based on super-strength
magnets not yet built--in, of all places, Tallahassee, Florida.
It was to be a start-up project of the first order, built literally from
scratch, founded on little else than the government's faith in what the people
in Tallahassee said they'd do if given the chance.
On June 22 of this year, an anxious crew of scientists and
engineers at FSU's Innovation Park threw a switch that
dumped enough power to light up 750 houses onto a made-in-
Tallahassee magnet--and held their breath. Within
minutes, the device did what it was designed to do--develop the greatest
field-strength of its class ever recorded.
From start-up to a world record in just under 48 months. A not-
insignificant segment of the world's science community found itself
surprised once again.
"I think the whole world felt like we wouldn't be able to do this
in 10 years," lab director Dr. Jack Crow opined. "But here, in just the
beginning of our fifth year, we will have leapfrogged every magnet lab in the
world."
The spectacularly successful testing of its first home-designed-
and-built magnet in June --coming as it did right on schedule--stands as
immutable proof that America's National High Magnetic Field Laboratory
(NHMFL) has arrived.
The event marked the scientific and technological apex of what
has been an unrelieved storm of physical and intellectual
activity at the lab's Innovation Park address since the fall of 1990.
The Shingle's Out
With Vice President Al Gore putting a proper
imprimatur on things at the lab's long-awaited dedication
ceremony in October, the operative phrase heard around Crow's
office nowadays is "tell 'em what we've got." Now that
the construction period has largely given way to the lab's all-
important research phase, Crow has swung the lab's doors
wide to scientists the world over. A key purpose of any national
lab is to put rare scientific instruments into the most
capable hands out there, and Crow is now obliged to jump from
being a construction foreman to a salesman.
"Now we've got a product, and it's our job to sell it," he told
Research in Review in August. "Everybody who's
been here is very impressed by what they see. But getting them
here for the first time is the challenge. Once they're here
and see these facilities, they usually walk away with their
mouths open."
Even to the scientifically disinclined, the lab presents an
imposing sight. Now with an in-house work force
approaching 250, there's sufficient activity in most corners of the
287,000-sq.-ft complex to create the aura of big-time
research, which in this case isn't pushing things to say big-time
adventure. Scientists--largely physicists, chemists and
mathematicians--mingle with engineers and technicians in
impromptu huddles called amid a chorus of whining
machines in the lab's cavernous central workshop. Inner works
of power distribution, cabling and mammoth-sized
plumbing offer a visual symphony of stainless steel, copper and
special alloys. Labs within labs brim with exquisite
species of electronic and mechanical gadgetry--most of it
spanking new. It may be the newness of everything, in fact,
that helps prompt the jaw-dropping reaction Crow speaks of.
Barring the foundation, the outer walls and the roof, the
building housing the lab's operational core bears little
resemblance to the one put up in 1989 by Innovation Park's
central authority as a home for a state testing facility. The
building, which was never occupied, was given a floor-to-ceiling
overhaul to accommodate its profoundly revised
mission. Then on the southwest side, a 27,000-sq.-ft. addition
was crafted to house a very special lab enterprise, the
world's largest center for investigating magnetic resonance (MR),
the phenomenon that has given rise to one of
medicine's most powerful diagnostic tools--MRI (for magnetic
resonance imaging).
Near the business end of the complex, where most of the lab's
biggest magnets already are, or will be, aligned in
concrete bays, a chiller plant throbs constantly, pulling down the
temperature of a recirculating, deionized water supply to
a steady 46°F. Thirty-six-inch mains carry the water to and from
a million-gallon cooling tower outside.
Cold water--lots of it--is the key to much of what goes on at the
lab. To build magnets hundreds of thousands of
times stronger that the earth's own magnetic field, huge
amounts of electricity must be applied in a relatively small
space--none of the magnets now on line at the lab is bigger than
a car engine. Such massive power coursing through
stacked copper plates--the magnets' "coils"--causes a fierce
amount of resistance expressed as heat. In the June
experiment, a magnetic field 600,000 times greater than Earth's
was created on the strength of 13.5 megawatts of power
poured into the lab's first resistive (heat-inducing) magnet.
Nearly 2,000 gallons per minute of chilled water, under 300
pounds of pressure, surged through the device and literally kept
it from melting.
Director Crow said that the June triumph has helped quiet much
of the criticism that arose in 1990 when the National
Science Foundation decided to shift the bulk of funding for its
high-field magnet development program from its
traditional home at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology to
Florida State. Fears that the move would doom MIT's
35-year-old Francis Bitter National Magnet Laboratory have
abated somewhat since then--Bitter is in line for continued
NSF funding through 1995, with the likelihood of renewed
contracts after that. Part of the reason is that the MIT group is
now heavily involved in collaborative projects with the
NHMFL team at FSU.
For starters, since MIT is a world leader in the design of so-called
"hybrid" magnets--giant-sized marriages of
resistive and superconducting magnet technologies, the Boston
group is helping build a super-hybrid model that is
scheduled to be installed at FSU next year and running by
September. This 14-ton, 21-foot-tall Goliath is being designed
to develop a magnetic field rated at 45-Tesla, a measurement
indicating strength. (By contrast, the world record set by the
FSU team in June with a conventional resistive magnet was 27-
T, snapping a 25-T mark held by the Max Planck Institute
in Grenoble, France. Outside of highly controlled experiments in
which colossal Tesla numbers are reached with the aid
of high explosives (work exclusively conducted by NHMFL's
western partner, Los Alamos National Laboratory in New
Mexico) a strength of 45-T, when achieved, will set the world
record for stand-alone magnets of any kind, says Crow.
"Right now, Grenoble is just starting to design their 43-T and
Japan, the next leading competitor, is starting a 40-T,"
said Crow. "So with our 45-T on line next September, we will be
in a position to go well beyond everybody else in the
world (in terms of raw power) and therefore the science coming
out of here should be well beyond everybody else, too."
Science is Job One
Lab scientists didn't waste much time celebrating the fact that
their new 27-T magnet actually worked just as its
designers said it would. Within hours of start-up, a group of
physicists led by Dr. William Moulton of FSU used the
device for an experiment in nuclear (there are several types)
MR--the first such investigation ever attempted at such a
high field level.
Since June, the lab has designed, built, installed and tested two
other large resistive magnets--another 27-T along
with a 20-T--and a 30-T is scheduled to be on line by the end of
this year. Also by January, installation of the lab's first
large-scale, superconducting magnet--a 20-T machine built on
contract with an English magnet design company--is
expected to finally usher in the science phase of the lab's NMR
program, delayed somewhat because of difficulty in
obtaining high-end equipment and in signing a bona fide, world-
renowned expert to run it. This summer, Dr. Geoffrey
Bodenhausen, director of the NMR program at the University of
Lausanne (Switzerland), assumed the reins of the young
program, joining a stellar line-up of talent drawn to the lab in
recent months.
The frenzy to acquire machines and personnel, of course, signals
a resolve to stop talking about science and start
doing it--a matter much on the mind of director Crow,
obviously. He's been encouraged by the interest shown by a
number of university groups--Louisiana State, UCLA, Boston,
SUNY-Buffalo and several German institutes--who've
already shown up for preliminary work in such areas as high-
temperature superconductivity and other aspects of
materials science. As word gets out about what the lab has to
offer, Crow expects an increase in the number of campus-
based science groups applying for time on the facilities, which--
as is the rule at all national labs--is free to qualified,
public users. Private companies, especially those involved in
proprietary work, have to pay, said Crow, but he doesn't
expect a great deal of interest from the private sector in the
initial going.
"Our emphasis right now is on convincing university scientists
that this facility will enhance their research. To justify
long-term funding, we've got to develop a customer base out
there that is writing to the NSF and saying 'for goodness
sake, make sure this place is properly funded.' We've got to get
them screaming if the product isn't available."
The "product" is soon to become appreciably better. In
September, the NSF announced that the lab had won a $5
million competition to develop the world's largest center for
research in the field of ion cyclotron mass spectrometry, a
new, high-end offshoot of NMR research that poses
revolutionary changes in fundamental studies of chemicals,
biological tissue and manmade materials. Crow
regards the news as the lab's "first big success story" in
the pursuit of uses for high-field magnets in science and
industry, the lab's fundamental reason for being.
The words come from the a final report of a panel of experts
convened by the National Science Foundation in 1988.
Panelists were charged with determining the intrinsic worth of
research in super-high magnetic fields and how exactly
U.S. work in the area stacked up against competition from
Europe and Japan. The panelists obviously found things
lacking in the American initiative and strongly recommended a
stepped-up emphasis on what they concluded was an area
of vital national interest.
Ergo, the NSF reexamined its funding priorities for high-field
research and issued a national call for proposals
basically aimed at building the world's preeminent center for
magnet research in America. An unlikely bid by FSU--
backed up by a pledge of $60 million in state dollars over a five-
year-period (matched by $60 million from the NSF)--
emerged as a strong contender right off the bat. The unusual
proposal called for a partnership between Florida State, the
University of Florida and New Mexico's Los Alamos National
Laboratory, a plan designed to capitalize on strengths in
materials science, cryogenics, biotechnology, both theoretical and
experimental physics, and advanced computing already
in place at these three sites.
Crow and his chief administrators keenly remember the wails of
protest that erupted in 1990 over the NSF's
subsequent decision to place its bet on the Florida plan. The
implication--that serious research can be done only in the
Northeast or on the Pacific coast--has most assuredly helped
keep the Florida group focused and on task. Crow says the
results are everywhere one cares to look.
"Not only are we on schedule with most of our (construction)
commitments, but we're actually ahead in a few key
areas," he said. "Our original schedule called for the installation
of the 45-T (hybrid) in 1997. We're going to have it up
and running in September of '95--two years early on that one."
A shortened timetable for getting such super-magnets on line
has been a consequence of an engineering tour de force
that produced quality infrastructure unlike any he's seen, said
Crow, who added that he's seen them all. Design and
performance of the lab's massive, 40-megawatt power supply--
the largest ever hitched to a magnet lab in this or any
other country--and the facility's elaborate, yet super-quiet
cooling system exceeded all specifications, and in some cases
by a factor of 10, he said.
The magnet that set the 27-T record in June not only hit its
mark, but amazed its designers with its reliability. In
September, the magnet was still running strong after more than
200 hours of operation. By contrast, lesser magnets at
MIT's Bitter lab are routinely replaced after 150 hours, said one
lab engineer.
The Force is With Us
Now that they're confident they've built the best facility
for magnet research on the planet, Crow's team is
anxious to see what it will do. Science at the lab's New Mexico
affiliate, as is well known among magnet designers, has
been under way for some time. That effort, directed by Dr. L.J.
Campbell, is pursuing studies of ultra-high magnetic
fields--far beyond anything within reach at Innovation Park.
These super-short-lived fields are generated by carefully
designed devices which use high explosives to force the creation
of fields in the 100-T to 200-T range. No practical uses
for such self-destructive machines have yet been proposed, yet
for scientists the research offers intriguing insights into
magnet theory, the fuel that drives the whole endeavor in high-
field science.
So far, magnet science at the University of Florida centers on
applications of high fields in research involving
superconductivity, the phenomenon--now restricted to super-
cold environments--whereby electricity flows with no
resistance. Superconductivity plays a key role in research at UF's
MicroKelvin Laboratory, where investigations of the
nature of exotic materials such as heavy fermion alloys are
conducted at some of the lowest temperatures ever created.
Magnets immersed in hyper-cooled baths of liquid helium or
nitrogen can run for years without consuming any
power, a phenomenon that has led high-field magnetism out of
the laboratory and into practical applications in science and
industry, the best example being MRI technology. As an
NHMFL affiliate, the University of Florida will soon be able to
equip its new $58 million Brain Institute with what is expected
to be the most powerful MRI system ever installed,
according to Dr. Tim Cross, deputy director of lab's NMR
program. The core of the system, which will be operational in
1997, will be two specially designed superconducting magnets,
the first of which already is on the drawing board in
Tallahassee. This 12-T unit will be capable of imaging whole,
live animals the size of rabbits or small dogs and in
unprecedented detail, Cross said. Dr. Tom Mareci, head of UF's
Center for Structural Biology, said this machine, along
with a 4-T instrument that will be capable of imaging whole
human brains and spinal cords, will represent the most
sophisticated MRI diagnostic lab in the world. Brain Institute
researchers expect to be able to use the lab to develop a
novel technique known as in vivo spectroscopy, which allows
scientists to examine the chemistry of live bodily organs
without harming or disturbing them in any way, Mareci said.
Once perfected, such a tool could be invaluable in the study
of brain function and in treating brain and spinal cord injuries,
he added.
But it's clearly at Innovation Park where most of the
consortium's frontier science will be conducted. Much of what
excites scientists familiar with high-field magnetics is the
potential this largely unexplored phenomenon has for
advancing fundamental knowledge of how molecules interact to form
things. When any material--be it natural, manmade, organic
or inorganic--is exposed to tremendous magnetic energy, the
submicroscopic beehive of atomic activity within it begins
to slow down. This brief hiatus in normally frenzied atomic
behavior presents an opportunity for scientists to study such
things as how atoms aggregate as molecules and how these, in
turn, associate with other molecules to form a gas, liquids
such as blood or crude oil, a piece of plastic or steel--in short,
anything--and often in stunning detail. Boosting the
power of magnets for such work is akin to cranking up the
magnification power of a microscope or telescope--one's
ability to see details (resolution) becomes increasingly more
acute.
Such a powerful analytical tool poses all sorts of uses in science
and technology, but none are now more obvious than
in the global quest for high-temperature ("high-TC")
superconductivity. The 1988 NSF panel, in fact, plainly
suggested that the key to achieving high-TC superconductivity--making
the phenomenon work at normal temperatures--lies within
high-magnetic field research.
Recognized as one of the true holy grails of science, high-TC
superconductivity is a supreme challenge relegated
almost exclusively to the study of new materials. This is where
the NHMFL headquarters is expected to shine. Crow &
Co. have succeeded in recruiting some of the world's best minds
in materials science and in particular, superconductivity.
The Nobel Prize that the lab's chief scientist, Dr. Robert L.
Schrieffer, shared with two other physicists in 1972 honored
his contributions to the fundamental theory underlying the
phenomenon. Heading the lab's theory group is Russian-born
Dr. Lev Gor'kov, whose pioneering work in superconductivity
theory won him his native country's highest science
honor--the Lenin Award in Physics--in 1966.
Of course, superconductivity won't just be studied at the lab--it
will be put to increasing use in the magnets scientists
will use there for years to come. The entire family of magnets
slated for use by the lab's Institute for Advanced Studies
of Magnetic Resonance are superconducting, many of them
commercially available this year for the first time--a
testimony to how fast the technology is growing. Such resources
will be shared by the institute's three in-house
programs: the NMR group headed by Bodenhausen; the ESR
(for electron spin resonance) group headed by Dr. Louis-
Claude Brunel, lured from Grenoble; and the ICR (ion cyclotron
resonance) group headed by Dr. Alan Marshall.
Research here will be given over entirely to finding the limits to
which these three related analytical techniques may be
taken in determining the molecular and atomic structures of
various materials, both natural and manmade.
Closing the Deal
With the stage now pretty much set, Crow is starting
the show with a plan to make the lab an even bigger
attraction for researchers. He's seeking private funding to build
a 15-unit guest house on the lab's premises to
accommodate visiting research groups. The idea is intended to
complement a state-funded, $1.2 million annual visitor
program that pays salaries to distinguished visiting scholars who
want to spend extended periods--of up to a year--in
Tallahassee.
Having on-site living quarters readily available to rank-and-file
users, most of whom would not qualify for support
through the state's visitor program, would help overcome one
of the lab's admitted disadvantages--its distance from
traditional research hubs in the Northeast and on the West
Coast, says Crow.
"Research funding is tight everywhere, so for people coming
from around the country, we can't have them spending
a lot on housing and transportation. That's just another
impediment for them to come here, see what we've got and use
it."
An axiom of salesmanship, Crow is learning, is that one does
whatever it takes to steer the customer to "yes."
National laboratories may represent some of the country's most
prized assemblages of scientific hardware and personnel,
but they fail utterly when they insulate themselves from the
scientific community at large, Crow feels. To prevent that, he
vows to make the nation's newest scientific gem as accessible as
possible to students, scholars and to industry as well to
keep ideas fresh--even to take risks, if that's what it takes.
"People are just beginning to hear about us, and there's a
learning curve involved," he said. "But that's to be expected. The word is
getting out about what we've got here, and we're confident that when people
see it for the first time, we won't have to worry--this incredible place will sell
itself."
--FRANK STEPHENSON
|